Feature Request: Idea for Spamblock (Bayes)

[seraphyn]

I talked with Dirk (Link is german http://www.deimeke.net/dirk/blog/index. ... s-....html) about der Plugin Spamblock (Bayes) if it wouldn't be nice to have an automatic upload option to share the csv-files together.
At the moment some posts their csv on the web, so it isn't easy to allocate them.
And we do not have problems like Akismet ae
It would be nice to have an option to enable/disable an automatic upload to an dedicated place of the database from the Spamplugin and to have the possibility to update the own database from this place.
If webspace needed I would provide some. Got a rootshell-less place, but unlimited traffic.
The Question is if something could be done from the developer of the plugin?
Greetings

[bernd_d]

Sounds nice so far...but what can be done against people who train one or more "bad" words as a "very good" and upload this rating to the server?

[seraphyn]

That's what I said to Dirk, too.
It would be nice to offer for upload a validation, but I got only something like a GPG-Signature in my mind.
But my coding in PHP this features is Pita lol
And validation of gpg-keys would be a nice web of trust imo..
Usable under Windows and X

[Lux]

Hi

I don't think we have to make it that difficult.

Just an automatically generated key, which is published somewhere in the blog.

If you want to import, you have to give the URL and the key.

That's it.

Cheers

Dirk

[onli]

Note that i described how such a system could work in german on dirks blog. Anybody needing a translation? Let's continue from there. Could that system work? Am i missing something?

[Lux]

Note that i described how such a system could work in german on dirks blog. Anybody needing a translation? Let's continue from there. Could that system work? Am i missing something?

I would not like to have a central service. In my opinion it would be better to have an interface in every blog and let the user decide which sources he/she wants to use.

Cheers

Dirk

[seraphyn]

I would not like to have a central service. In my opinion it would be better to have an interface in every blog and let the user decide which sources he/she wants to use.

As far as I know there are only 2 sources I really know, yours Dirk and YellowLeds.
It's not easy to find sources, so should there be a central service, that provides defined sources from others members like repositories (URLs) and it is possibles to set up a sources.list in the Plugin
Greets

[onli]

I'm with both of you on this. Having this not decentraliced would be great. But seraphyn is right, when starting a blog, you need an easy way to add this. There is no use in bulding this if only experienced bloggers, with friends who use the system, may use that - they probably have fully configured filters anyway.
Apart from that: I never liked letting serendipity do things in the future, it never worked totally as expected - and this is nothing you want to start when someone visits a page.

[bernd_d]

Stupid question: What about privacy inside this database? For example author or e-mail? Or do you think it isn't a problem because the words are saved as single entrys, not in a context?

[kleinerChemiker]

At least in Germany it could be a problem. at least email is a privat data and if you send it to other servers, you have to ask the user.

[onli]

Or do you think it isn't a problem because the words are saved as single entrys, not in a context?

I think so. They are tokenized anyway, pretty hard to reconstruct.

[seraphyn]

What about not to serve Mailadresses and IPs
URLs in comments are known to be public, usernames as well.
Makes it a lil bit absurd but the judges will like it honestly... and me too
Don't thought about it.
But best for bayes is the URLs and text given in the comments, isn't it?
Chris

[seraphyn]

I just would like to bump it up and to ask if something new about this project?
chris

[onli]

At the moment, i have a working prototype of such a system working on my local system. We got strange errors when trying to run it on Dirks server and it is stalling there.

[seraphyn]

Nice.
Is there an SVN or a Projecthomepage?
Chris